
The Russian Revolution
The Russian Revolution
Richard Pipes’sTHE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION“Masterful and timely … [Pipes’s] history blends uncannily with today’s … headlines.… A brilliantly focused portrait.”—Newsweek“Pipes’s compellingly written account … is … a masterful culmination of his lifelong investigations of the revolutionary period.”—Newsday“A truly impressive piece of scholarship … A fascinating treatise, certain to become the basic research text on the subject.”—Philadelphia Inquirer“Panoramic … The first attempt in any language to offer a comprehensive study of the Russian Revolution … Pipes is not a mere communicator of facts but a philosopher examining the deeper, broader trends beneath the surface of history.”—San Francisco Chronicle“Like his illustrious predecessor among students of revolutions, Alexis de Tocqueville, Pipes has a broad, sweeping view.… An imposing achievement … His craftsmanship as a writer … serves him well.”—Boston Globe“Pipes is an extremely knowledgeable and careful historian.… This is probably the best overall study of those momentous events … a good, important book.”—Cleveland Plain DealerPART ONE The Agony of the Old Regime1 1905: The ForeshockUniversity disturbances of 1899 as beginning of revolutionPlehve and Zubatovoutbreak of Russo-Japanese War, Plehve assassinated and replaced by Mirskii: the great Zemstvo Congress (November 1904)“Bloody Sunday”tsarism tries moderate reformsthe debacle of Tsushima and talk of a representative bodyuniversity turmoil resumes and leads to general strikeWitte advises concessionsemergence of St. Petersburg Sovietthe October ManifestoWitte forms cabinet and represses radicals; nationwide pogroms1905 as apogee of Russian liberalism2 Official RussiaPatrimonialismNicholas and Alexandrathe bureaucracyministriesconservative and liberal officialdomeconomic development undermines autocracythe armythe gentrythe Orthodox church3 Rural RussiaHousehold, village, and communeland shortageindustrial workerspeasant mentalitypeasant attitudes to law and propertychanges in peasant mood after 19004 The IntelligentsiaIts European originssociétés de penséesocialism as ideology of the intelligentsiathe ideal of a “new man”emergence of Russian intelligentsiarevolutionary movement in nineteenth century Russiathe Socialists-RevolutionariesRussian liberals5 The Constitutional ExperimentMonarchy and constitutionalismthe Fundamental Laws of 1906elections to the Dumathe First DumaStolypinStolypin represses terrorhis agrarian reformsthe Second Duma and the electoral law of June 3, 1907Stolypin’s political difficulties beginthe Western zemstvo crisisStolypins murderassessment of StolypinRussia on the eve of World War I6 Russia at WarStrategic preparations and Russia’s readiness for warearly campaigns: East Prussia and GaliciaRussian debacle in Poland, 1915changes in governmentemergence of the Progressive Bloc and Nicholas’s assumption of high commandbringing society into limited partnership in the war effort7 Toward the CatastropheInflationthe Brusilov offensiverise of tension in the countryfood crisisProtopopovthe liberals decide to attackDuma sessions of November 1916assassination of Rasputinlast days at Tsarskoe Seloplots against the Imperial family8 The February RevolutionMutiny of Petrograd garrisonthe Duma hesitates to claim poweremergence of Petrograd Soviet and of its Executive CommitteeDuma and Soviet agree on formation of Provisional GovernmentOrder No. 1abdication of Nicholas IIMichael refuses the crownearly actions of Provisional GovernmentSoviet undermines the governmentland, Constituent Assembly, and war aimsrevolution spreads nationwideex-tsar returns to Tsarskoe Seloextraordinary rapidity of Russia’s breakdownPART TWO The Bolsheviks Conquer Russia9 Lenin and the Origins of BolshevismLenin’s early yearsLenin and Social Democracyhis personalityhis disenchantment with Social Democracyemergence of Bolshevismfinal split with the MensheviksLenin’s agrarian and nationality programsfinancial affairs of the Bolshevik partythe Malinovskii episodeZimmerwald, Kiental, and connections with enemy agents10 The Bolshevik Bid for PowerThe Bolshevik Party in early 1917Lenin returns to Russia with German helpLenin’s revolutionary tacticsthe April 1917 Bolshevik demonstrationsocialists enter Provisional GovernmentBolshevik assets in the struggle for power and German subsidiesthe aborted Bolshevik street action in JuneKerensky’s summer offensivethe Bolsheviks ready another assaultpreparation for putschthe events of July 3–5the putsch suppressed: Lenin flees, Kerensky dictator11 The October CoupKornilov appointed Commander in ChiefKerensky asks Kornilov’s help in suppressing anticipated Bolshevik coupthe break between Kerensky and Kornilovrise in Bolshevik fortunesLenin in hidingBolsheviks plan their own Congress of SovietsBolsheviks take over Soviet’s Military-Revolutionary Committeethe critical decision of October 10Milrevkom initiatescoup d’étatKerensky reactsBolsheviks declare Provisional Government overthrownthe Second Congress of Soviets ratifies passage of power and passes laws on peace and landBolshevik coup in Moscowfew aware of what had transpired12 Building the One-Party StateLenin’s strategy after power seizureLenin and Trotsky rid themselves of accountability to the Central Executive Committee of the Sovietstrike of white collar employeesthe Council of People’s Commissarsaccord with Left SRs and the breakup of the Peasant Congresselections to the Constituent Assemblydecision to be rid of itthe dissolution of the Assemblyeffects and implicationsmovement of Worker Plenipotentiaries13 Brest-LitovskBolsheviks and traditional diplomacyGerman and Bolshevik approaches to talksdivisions in the Bolshevik commandinitial negotiationsTrotsky at Brestbitter divisions among Bolsheviks and the German ultimatumGermans decide to be firmthey advance into Soviet RussiaAllied efforts to win over BolsheviksMoscow requests Allied helpRussians capitulate to German termsSoviet government moves to Moscowterms of Brest-Litovsk Treatyfirst Allied landings in RussiaAmerican reaction to Bolshevik policiesprinciples of Bolshevik foreign policy14 The Revolution InternationalizedSmall Western interest in Russian Revolutionfoundations of Red Army laidfurther talks with AlliesGerman embassy arrives in MoscowSoviet embassy in Berlin and its subversive activitiesthe Czechoslovak rebellionBolsheviks adopt military conscriptionCzech advancesthe Kaiser decides to continue pro-Bolshevik policythe Left SRs plot uprisingthey kill Mirbachsuppression of their rebellionSavinkovs clandestine organizationthe Iaroslavl risingRiezler fails in attempt to reorient German policyfurther Allied activities on Russian soilBolsheviks request German interventionSupplementary Treaty with GermanyRussians decide the Germans have lost the warthe problem of foreign “intervention”15 “War Communism”Its origins and objectives“Left Communists”plan implementationattempts to abolish moneycreation of Supreme Economic Councildecline of industrial productivitydecline of agricultural productivityefforts to abolish the market and the growth of a shadow economyanti-labor legislationtrade union policyeffects of War Communism16 War on the VillageBolsheviks view peasants as class enemywhat peasants gained in 1917–18 and at what costfood requisition policies and hunger in the citiescampaign against the village begins, May 1918food supply detachments meet with resistance: massive peasant revolt“Committees of the Poor”assessment of the campaign17 Murder of the Imperial FamilyRussian regicide uniquethe ex-tsar and family in the first months of Bolshevik ruleEkaterinburg Bolsheviks want ex-tsar in their custodyNicholas and Alexandra transported to Ekaterinburgthe “House of Special Designation”murder of Michael as trial baloonCheka fabricates rescue operationdecision to kill ex-tsar taken in Moscow: Cheka takes over guard dutiesthe murderdisposal of the remainsassassination of other members of the Imperial family at AlapaevskMoscow announces execution of Nicholas but not of familyimplications of these events18 The Red TerrorLenin’s attitude toward terrorabolition of laworigins of the ChekaCheka’s conflict with the Commissariat of JusticeLenin shot, August 30, 1918background of this event and beginning of Lenin cult“Red Terror” officially launchedmass murder of hostagessome Bolsheviks revolted by bloodbathCheka penetrates all Soviet institutionsBolsheviks create concentration campsvictims of Red Terrorforeign reactionsAfterwordGlossaryChronologyNotesOne Hundred Works on the Russian RevolutionINTRODUCTIONThis book is the first attempt in any language to present a comprehensive view of the Russian Revolution, arguably the most important event of the century. There is no shortage of surveys of the subject, but they concentrate on the political and military struggles for power over Russia between 1917 and 1920. Seen from the perspective of time, however, the Russian Revolution was a great deal more than a contest for power in one country: what the victors in that contest had in mind was defined by one of its leading protagonists, Leon Trotsky, as no less than “overturning the world.” By that was meant a complete redesign of state, society, economy, and culture all over the world for the ultimate purpose of creating a new human being.These far-reaching implications of the Russian Revolution were not evident in 1917–18, in part because the West considered Russia to lie on the periphery of the civilized world and in part because the Revolution there occurred in the midst of a World War of unprecedented destructiveness. In 1917–18 it was believed by virtually all non-Russians that what had occurred in Russia was of exclusively local importance, irrelevant to them and in any event bound to settle down once peace had been restored. It turned out otherwise. The repercussions of the Russian Revolution would be felt in every corner of the globe for the rest of the century.Events of such magnitude have neither a clear beginning nor a neat end. Historians have long argued over the terminal dates of the Middle Ages, the Renaissance, and the Enlightenment. Similarly, there is no indisputable way to determine the time span of the Russian Revolution. What can be said with certainty is that it did not begin with the collapse of tsarism in February–March 1917 and conclude with the Bolshevik victory in the Civil War three years later. The revolutionary movement became an intrinsic element of Russian history as early as the 1860s. The first phase of the Russian Revolution in the narrow sense of the word (corresponding to the constitutional phase of the French Revolution, 1789–92) began with the violence of 1905. This was brought under control by a combination of concessions and repression, but violence resumed on an even grander scale after a hiatus of twelve years, in February 1917, culminating in the Bolshevik coup d’etat of October. After three years of fighting against internal and external opponents, the Bolsheviks succeeded in establishing undisputed mastery over most of what had been the Russian Empire. But they were as yet too weak to realize their ambitious program of economic, social, and cultural transformation. This had to be postponed for several years to give the ravaged country time to recover. The Revolution was resumed in 1927–28 and consummated ten years later after frightful upheavals that claimed millions of lives. It may be said to have run its course only with the death of Stalin in 1953, when his successors initiated and carried out, by fits and starts, a kind of counterrevolution from above, which in 1990 appears to have led to a rejection of a good part of the Revolution’s legacy.Broadly defined, the Russian Revolution may thus be said to have lasted a century. A process of such duration in a country of Russia’s size and population was bound to be exceedingly complex. An autocratic monarchy that had ruled Russia since the fourteenth century could no longer cope with the demands of modernity and gradually lost out to a radical intelligentsia in whom commitment to extreme Utopian ideas combined with a boundless lust for power. Like all such drawn-out processes, however, it had its culminating period. In my estimation, that period was the quarter of a century extending from the outbreak of large-scale unrest at Russian universities in February 1899 to the death of Lenin in January 1924.Because the aspirations of the intellectuals who assumed power in October 1917 were so extreme, I found it necessary to treat many topics besides the customary political-military power struggle. To the Russian revolutionaries, power was merely a means to an end, which was the remaking of the human species. In the first years of their rule they lacked the strength to attain an objective so contrary to what their people desired, but they did try and in so doing laid the foundations of the Stalinist regime, which would resume the attempt with far greater resources. I devote considerable attention to these social, economic, and cultural antecedents of Stalinism, which, even if only imperfectly realized under Lenin, from the outset lay at the very heart of the Russian Revolution.This volume is divided into two parts.Part I, “The Agony of the Old Regime,” describes the decay of tsarism, culminating in the mutiny of the Petrograd military garrison in February 1917, which in surprisingly short time not only brought down the monarchy but tore apart the country’s political and social fabric. It is a continuation of my Russia under the Old Regime, which traced the development of the Russian state and society from their origins to the end of the nineteenth century. Part II, “The Bolsheviks Conquer Russia,” recounts how the Bolshevik Party seized power first in Petrograd and then in the provinces inhabited by Great Russians, imposing on this region a one-party regime with its terror apparatus and centralized economic system. Both these parts appear in the present volume. A sequel, Russia under the New Regime, will deal with the Civil War, the separation and reintegration of the non-Russian borderlands, Soviet Russia’s international activities, Bolshevik cultural policies, and the Communist regime as it took shape in the final year of Lenin’s dictatorship.The difficulties confronting a historian of a subject of such complexity and magnitude are formidable. They are not, however, as is commonly believed, caused by a shortage of sources: although some of these are, indeed, inaccessible (especially documents bearing on Bolshevik decision-making), the source materials are quite sufficient, far beyond the capacity of any individual to absorb. The historian’s problem, rather, is that the Russian Revolution, being part of our own time, is difficult to deal with dispassionately. The Soviet Government, which controls the bulk of the source materials and dominates the historiography, derives its legitimacy from the Revolution and wants it treated in a manner supportive of its claims. By single-mindedly shaping the image of the Revolution over decades it has succeeded in determining not only how the events are treated but which of them are treated. Among the many subjects that it has confined to historiographic limbo are the role of the liberals in the 1905 and 1917 revolutions; the conspiratorial manner in which the Bolsheviks seized power in October; the overwhelming rejection of Bolshevik rule half a year after it had come into being, by all classes, including the workers; Communist relations with Imperial Germany in 1917–1918; the military campaign of 1918 against the Russian village; and the famine of 1921, which claimed the lives of over five million people. Writing a scholarly history of the Russian Revolution, therefore, demands, in addition to absorbing an immense mass of facts, also breaking out of the mental straitjacket that seventy years of politically directed historiography have managed to impose on the profession. This situation is not unique to Russia. In France, too, the revolution was for a long time mainly grist for political polemics: the first academic chair devoted to its history was founded at the Sorbonne only in the 1880s, a century after the event, when the Third Republic was in place and 1789 could be treated with some degree of dispassion. And still the controversy has never abated.But even approached in a scholarly manner, the history of modern revolutions cannot be value-free: I have yet to read an account of the French or the Russian revolution that does not reveal, despite most authors’ intention to appear impartial, where the writer’s sympathies lie. The reason is not far to seek. Post-1789 revolutions have raised the most fundamental ethical questions: whether it is proper to destroy institutions built over centuries by trial and error, for the sake of ideal systems; whether one has the right to sacrifice the well-being and even the lives of one’s own generation for the sake of generations yet unborn; whether man can be refashioned into a perfectly virtuous being. To ignore these questions, raised already by Edmund Burke two centuries ago, is to turn a blind eye to the passions that had inspired those who made and those who resisted revolutions. For post-1789 revolutionary struggles, in the final analysis, are not over politics but over theology.This being the case, scholarship requires the historian to treat critically his sources and to render honestly the information he obtains from them. It does not call for ethical nihilism, that is, accepting that whatever happened had to happen and hence is beyond good and evil: the sentiment of the Russian philosopher Nicholas Berdiaev, who claimed that one could no more judge the Russian Revolution than the coming of the Ice Age or the fall of the Roman Empire. The Russian Revolution was made neither by the forces of nature nor by anonymous masses but by identifiable men pursuing their own advantages. Although it had spontaneous aspects, in the main it was the result of deliberate action. As such it is very properly subject to value judgment.Recently, some French historians have called for an end to the discussion of the causes and meaning of the French Revolution, declaring it to be “terminated.” But an occurrence that raises such fundamental philosophical and moral questions can never end. For the dispute is not only over what has happened in the past but also over what may happen in the future.Richard PipesChesham, New HampshireMay 1989
Richard Pipes’sTHE RUSSIAN REVOLUTION“Masterful and timely … [Pipes’s] history blends uncannily with today’s … headlines.… A brilliantly focused portrait.”—Newsweek“Pipes’s compellingly written account … is … a masterful culmination of his lifelong investigations of the revolutionary period.”—Newsday“A truly impressive piece of scholarship … A fascinating treatise, certain to become the basic research text on the subject.”—Philadelphia Inquirer“Panoramic … The first attempt in any language to offer a comprehensive study of the Russian Revolution … Pipes is not a mere communicator of facts but a philosopher examining the deeper, broader trends beneath the surface of history.”—San Francisco Chronicle“Like his illustrious predecessor among students of revolutions, Alexis de Tocqueville, Pipes has a broad, sweeping view.… An imposing achievement … His craftsmanship as a writer … serves him well.”—Boston Globe“Pipes is an extremely knowledgeable and careful historian.… This is probably the best overall study of those momentous events … a good, important book.”—Cleveland Plain DealerPART ONE The Agony of the Old Regime1 1905: The ForeshockUniversity disturbances of 1899 as beginning of revolutionPlehve and Zubatovoutbreak of Russo-Japanese War, Plehve assassinated and replaced by Mirskii: the great Zemstvo Congress (November 1904)“Bloody Sunday”tsarism tries moderate reformsthe debacle of Tsushima and talk of a representative bodyuniversity turmoil resumes and leads to general strikeWitte advises concessionsemergence of St. Petersburg Sovietthe October ManifestoWitte forms cabinet and represses radicals; nationwide pogroms1905 as apogee of Russian liberalism2 Official RussiaPatrimonialismNicholas and Alexandrathe bureaucracyministriesconservative and liberal officialdomeconomic development undermines autocracythe armythe gentrythe Orthodox church3 Rural RussiaHousehold, village, and communeland shortageindustrial workerspeasant mentalitypeasant attitudes to law and propertychanges in peasant mood after 19004 The IntelligentsiaIts European originssociétés de penséesocialism as ideology of the intelligentsiathe ideal of a “new man”emergence of Russian intelligentsiarevolutionary movement in nineteenth century Russiathe Socialists-RevolutionariesRussian liberals5 The Constitutional ExperimentMonarchy and constitutionalismthe Fundamental Laws of 1906elections to the Dumathe First DumaStolypinStolypin represses terrorhis agrarian reformsthe Second Duma and the electoral law of June 3, 1907Stolypin’s political difficulties beginthe Western zemstvo crisisStolypins murderassessment of StolypinRussia on the eve of World War I6 Russia at WarStrategic preparations and Russia’s readiness for warearly campaigns: East Prussia and GaliciaRussian debacle in Poland, 1915changes in governmentemergence of the Progressive Bloc and Nicholas’s assumption of high commandbringing society into limited partnership in the war effort7 Toward the CatastropheInflationthe Brusilov offensiverise of tension in the countryfood crisisProtopopovthe liberals decide to attackDuma sessions of November 1916assassination of Rasputinlast days at Tsarskoe Seloplots against the Imperial family8 The February RevolutionMutiny of Petrograd garrisonthe Duma hesitates to claim poweremergence of Petrograd Soviet and of its Executive CommitteeDuma and Soviet agree on formation of Provisional GovernmentOrder No. 1abdication of Nicholas IIMichael refuses the crownearly actions of Provisional GovernmentSoviet undermines the governmentland, Constituent Assembly, and war aimsrevolution spreads nationwideex-tsar returns to Tsarskoe Seloextraordinary rapidity of Russia’s breakdownPART TWO The Bolsheviks Conquer Russia9 Lenin and the Origins of BolshevismLenin’s early yearsLenin and Social Democracyhis personalityhis disenchantment with Social Democracyemergence of Bolshevismfinal split with the MensheviksLenin’s agrarian and nationality programsfinancial affairs of the Bolshevik partythe Malinovskii episodeZimmerwald, Kiental, and connections with enemy agents10 The Bolshevik Bid for PowerThe Bolshevik Party in early 1917Lenin returns to Russia with German helpLenin’s revolutionary tacticsthe April 1917 Bolshevik demonstrationsocialists enter Provisional GovernmentBolshevik assets in the struggle for power and German subsidiesthe aborted Bolshevik street action in JuneKerensky’s summer offensivethe Bolsheviks ready another assaultpreparation for putschthe events of July 3–5the putsch suppressed: Lenin flees, Kerensky dictator11 The October CoupKornilov appointed Commander in ChiefKerensky asks Kornilov’s help in suppressing anticipated Bolshevik coupthe break between Kerensky and Kornilovrise in Bolshevik fortunesLenin in hidingBolsheviks plan their own Congress of SovietsBolsheviks take over Soviet’s Military-Revolutionary Committeethe critical decision of October 10Milrevkom initiatescoup d’étatKerensky reactsBolsheviks declare Provisional Government overthrownthe Second Congress of Soviets ratifies passage of power and passes laws on peace and landBolshevik coup in Moscowfew aware of what had transpired12 Building the One-Party StateLenin’s strategy after power seizureLenin and Trotsky rid themselves of accountability to the Central Executive Committee of the Sovietstrike of white collar employeesthe Council of People’s Commissarsaccord with Left SRs and the breakup of the Peasant Congresselections to the Constituent Assemblydecision to be rid of itthe dissolution of the Assemblyeffects and implicationsmovement of Worker Plenipotentiaries13 Brest-LitovskBolsheviks and traditional diplomacyGerman and Bolshevik approaches to talksdivisions in the Bolshevik commandinitial negotiationsTrotsky at Brestbitter divisions among Bolsheviks and the German ultimatumGermans decide to be firmthey advance into Soviet RussiaAllied efforts to win over BolsheviksMoscow requests Allied helpRussians capitulate to German termsSoviet government moves to Moscowterms of Brest-Litovsk Treatyfirst Allied landings in RussiaAmerican reaction to Bolshevik policiesprinciples of Bolshevik foreign policy14 The Revolution InternationalizedSmall Western interest in Russian Revolutionfoundations of Red Army laidfurther talks with AlliesGerman embassy arrives in MoscowSoviet embassy in Berlin and its subversive activitiesthe Czechoslovak rebellionBolsheviks adopt military conscriptionCzech advancesthe Kaiser decides to continue pro-Bolshevik policythe Left SRs plot uprisingthey kill Mirbachsuppression of their rebellionSavinkovs clandestine organizationthe Iaroslavl risingRiezler fails in attempt to reorient German policyfurther Allied activities on Russian soilBolsheviks request German interventionSupplementary Treaty with GermanyRussians decide the Germans have lost the warthe problem of foreign “intervention”15 “War Communism”Its origins and objectives“Left Communists”plan implementationattempts to abolish moneycreation of Supreme Economic Councildecline of industrial productivitydecline of agricultural productivityefforts to abolish the market and the growth of a shadow economyanti-labor legislationtrade union policyeffects of War Communism16 War on the VillageBolsheviks view peasants as class enemywhat peasants gained in 1917–18 and at what costfood requisition policies and hunger in the citiescampaign against the village begins, May 1918food supply detachments meet with resistance: massive peasant revolt“Committees of the Poor”assessment of the campaign17 Murder of the Imperial FamilyRussian regicide uniquethe ex-tsar and family in the first months of Bolshevik ruleEkaterinburg Bolsheviks want ex-tsar in their custodyNicholas and Alexandra transported to Ekaterinburgthe “House of Special Designation”murder of Michael as trial baloonCheka fabricates rescue operationdecision to kill ex-tsar taken in Moscow: Cheka takes over guard dutiesthe murderdisposal of the remainsassassination of other members of the Imperial family at AlapaevskMoscow announces execution of Nicholas but not of familyimplications of these events18 The Red TerrorLenin’s attitude toward terrorabolition of laworigins of the ChekaCheka’s conflict with the Commissariat of JusticeLenin shot, August 30, 1918background of this event and beginning of Lenin cult“Red Terror” officially launchedmass murder of hostagessome Bolsheviks revolted by bloodbathCheka penetrates all Soviet institutionsBolsheviks create concentration campsvictims of Red Terrorforeign reactionsAfterwordGlossaryChronologyNotesOne Hundred Works on the Russian RevolutionINTRODUCTIONThis book is the first attempt in any language to present a comprehensive view of the Russian Revolution, arguably the most important event of the century. There is no shortage of surveys of the subject, but they concentrate on the political and military struggles for power over Russia between 1917 and 1920. Seen from the perspective of time, however, the Russian Revolution was a great deal more than a contest for power in one country: what the victors in that contest had in mind was defined by one of its leading protagonists, Leon Trotsky, as no less than “overturning the world.” By that was meant a complete redesign of state, society, economy, and culture all over the world for the ultimate purpose of creating a new human being.These far-reaching implications of the Russian Revolution were not evident in 1917–18, in part because the West considered Russia to lie on the periphery of the civilized world and in part because the Revolution there occurred in the midst of a World War of unprecedented destructiveness. In 1917–18 it was believed by virtually all non-Russians that what had occurred in Russia was of exclusively local importance, irrelevant to them and in any event bound to settle down once peace had been restored. It turned out otherwise. The repercussions of the Russian Revolution would be felt in every corner of the globe for the rest of the century.Events of such magnitude have neither a clear beginning nor a neat end. Historians have long argued over the terminal dates of the Middle Ages, the Renaissance, and the Enlightenment. Similarly, there is no indisputable way to determine the time span of the Russian Revolution. What can be said with certainty is that it did not begin with the collapse of tsarism in February–March 1917 and conclude with the Bolshevik victory in the Civil War three years later. The revolutionary movement became an intrinsic element of Russian history as early as the 1860s. The first phase of the Russian Revolution in the narrow sense of the word (corresponding to the constitutional phase of the French Revolution, 1789–92) began with the violence of 1905. This was brought under control by a combination of concessions and repression, but violence resumed on an even grander scale after a hiatus of twelve years, in February 1917, culminating in the Bolshevik coup d’etat of October. After three years of fighting against internal and external opponents, the Bolsheviks succeeded in establishing undisputed mastery over most of what had been the Russian Empire. But they were as yet too weak to realize their ambitious program of economic, social, and cultural transformation. This had to be postponed for several years to give the ravaged country time to recover. The Revolution was resumed in 1927–28 and consummated ten years later after frightful upheavals that claimed millions of lives. It may be said to have run its course only with the death of Stalin in 1953, when his successors initiated and carried out, by fits and starts, a kind of counterrevolution from above, which in 1990 appears to have led to a rejection of a good part of the Revolution’s legacy.Broadly defined, the Russian Revolution may thus be said to have lasted a century. A process of such duration in a country of Russia’s size and population was bound to be exceedingly complex. An autocratic monarchy that had ruled Russia since the fourteenth century could no longer cope with the demands of modernity and gradually lost out to a radical intelligentsia in whom commitment to extreme Utopian ideas combined with a boundless lust for power. Like all such drawn-out processes, however, it had its culminating period. In my estimation, that period was the quarter of a century extending from the outbreak of large-scale unrest at Russian universities in February 1899 to the death of Lenin in January 1924.Because the aspirations of the intellectuals who assumed power in October 1917 were so extreme, I found it necessary to treat many topics besides the customary political-military power struggle. To the Russian revolutionaries, power was merely a means to an end, which was the remaking of the human species. In the first years of their rule they lacked the strength to attain an objective so contrary to what their people desired, but they did try and in so doing laid the foundations of the Stalinist regime, which would resume the attempt with far greater resources. I devote considerable attention to these social, economic, and cultural antecedents of Stalinism, which, even if only imperfectly realized under Lenin, from the outset lay at the very heart of the Russian Revolution.This volume is divided into two parts.Part I, “The Agony of the Old Regime,” describes the decay of tsarism, culminating in the mutiny of the Petrograd military garrison in February 1917, which in surprisingly short time not only brought down the monarchy but tore apart the country’s political and social fabric. It is a continuation of my Russia under the Old Regime, which traced the development of the Russian state and society from their origins to the end of the nineteenth century. Part II, “The Bolsheviks Conquer Russia,” recounts how the Bolshevik Party seized power first in Petrograd and then in the provinces inhabited by Great Russians, imposing on this region a one-party regime with its terror apparatus and centralized economic system. Both these parts appear in the present volume. A sequel, Russia under the New Regime, will deal with the Civil War, the separation and reintegration of the non-Russian borderlands, Soviet Russia’s international activities, Bolshevik cultural policies, and the Communist regime as it took shape in the final year of Lenin’s dictatorship.The difficulties confronting a historian of a subject of such complexity and magnitude are formidable. They are not, however, as is commonly believed, caused by a shortage of sources: although some of these are, indeed, inaccessible (especially documents bearing on Bolshevik decision-making), the source materials are quite sufficient, far beyond the capacity of any individual to absorb. The historian’s problem, rather, is that the Russian Revolution, being part of our own time, is difficult to deal with dispassionately. The Soviet Government, which controls the bulk of the source materials and dominates the historiography, derives its legitimacy from the Revolution and wants it treated in a manner supportive of its claims. By single-mindedly shaping the image of the Revolution over decades it has succeeded in determining not only how the events are treated but which of them are treated. Among the many subjects that it has confined to historiographic limbo are the role of the liberals in the 1905 and 1917 revolutions; the conspiratorial manner in which the Bolsheviks seized power in October; the overwhelming rejection of Bolshevik rule half a year after it had come into being, by all classes, including the workers; Communist relations with Imperial Germany in 1917–1918; the military campaign of 1918 against the Russian village; and the famine of 1921, which claimed the lives of over five million people. Writing a scholarly history of the Russian Revolution, therefore, demands, in addition to absorbing an immense mass of facts, also breaking out of the mental straitjacket that seventy years of politically directed historiography have managed to impose on the profession. This situation is not unique to Russia. In France, too, the revolution was for a long time mainly grist for political polemics: the first academic chair devoted to its history was founded at the Sorbonne only in the 1880s, a century after the event, when the Third Republic was in place and 1789 could be treated with some degree of dispassion. And still the controversy has never abated.But even approached in a scholarly manner, the history of modern revolutions cannot be value-free: I have yet to read an account of the French or the Russian revolution that does not reveal, despite most authors’ intention to appear impartial, where the writer’s sympathies lie. The reason is not far to seek. Post-1789 revolutions have raised the most fundamental ethical questions: whether it is proper to destroy institutions built over centuries by trial and error, for the sake of ideal systems; whether one has the right to sacrifice the well-being and even the lives of one’s own generation for the sake of generations yet unborn; whether man can be refashioned into a perfectly virtuous being. To ignore these questions, raised already by Edmund Burke two centuries ago, is to turn a blind eye to the passions that had inspired those who made and those who resisted revolutions. For post-1789 revolutionary struggles, in the final analysis, are not over politics but over theology.This being the case, scholarship requires the historian to treat critically his sources and to render honestly the information he obtains from them. It does not call for ethical nihilism, that is, accepting that whatever happened had to happen and hence is beyond good and evil: the sentiment of the Russian philosopher Nicholas Berdiaev, who claimed that one could no more judge the Russian Revolution than the coming of the Ice Age or the fall of the Roman Empire. The Russian Revolution was made neither by the forces of nature nor by anonymous masses but by identifiable men pursuing their own advantages. Although it had spontaneous aspects, in the main it was the result of deliberate action. As such it is very properly subject to value judgment.Recently, some French historians have called for an end to the discussion of the causes and meaning of the French Revolution, declaring it to be “terminated.” But an occurrence that raises such fundamental philosophical and moral questions can never end. For the dispute is not only over what has happened in the past but also over what may happen in the future.Richard PipesChesham, New HampshireMay 1989
